Strategic acquisitions remain a potent option for fast-tracking revenue growth, diversifying service and product offerings, accessing vital Intellectual Property, and deepening human capital.

If you aspire to make acquisitions but haven’t started yet, or you’ve launched a search and it isn’t yielding results, here is a practical, six-step process to help you succeed and secure a genuine return on your investment.

1. Define Clear Acquisition Criteria

Be entirely clear on what you want to buy and why. If you are interested in acquisitions, there must be a compelling strategic driver. Aside from ultimately wanting to improve profitability, you need to know why an acquisition is the best way to:

• Address current shortcomings in your business.

• Capitalise effectively on latent market opportunities.

• Solve other critical scale barriers.

At its core, your team is deciding between building a solution in-house or buying it via an acquisition.

Successfully establishing organization-wide clarity on this "build vs. buy" dilemma requires input from all core business functions—including corporate strategy, sales, marketing, HR, and finance. While harnessing these diverse internal perspectives into a cohesive agreement can be a challenge, it is the only way to properly flesh out the criteria you need to target the right businesses.

"Developing the 'right' set of criteria is challenging, but without it, your search will be completely lost."

Rather than shooting for a "perfect" framework—which inevitably delays getting started—the best approach is to develop a workable set of baseline criteria. You can then refine these over a 3-to-6-month period based on real-world feedback and interactions with potential targets.

2. Embrace Proactive Searching

If your acquisition strategy relies on diligently browsing business-for-sale websites or waiting for "business for sale or merge" ads to pop up in industry publications, it will likely fail. The probability of a perfect strategic acquisition dropping into your lap this way is remote.

The good news is that the "hidden sale market" is massive. The number of owners open to a strategic conversation—even though they aren't formally advertising their business for sale—outnumbers listed businesses by a factor of up to ten to one.

This disparity is consistently borne out in our advisory work. For example, during desktop research for a recent client, we identified 24 companies as potential acquisition targets. Our first discrete contact generated initial discussions with 7 of those 24 companies (none of which were actively for sale). By the second contact, we were in discussions with 11.

With systematic follow-up, a buyer can realistically expect to hold general-level discussions with 12 to 14 targets, ultimately identifying 1 to 3 high-value opportunities. The single biggest determinant of achieving this depth of market penetration is the upfront effort you put into your targeting criteria.

3. Harvest the Deal Pipeline

The hidden sale market is incredibly significant, but you must actively harvest your leads. Strategic acquisition opportunities almost always take longer to finalize than you think.

The M&A process involves constant ebbs and flows. Prospective sellers change their minds due to unexpected business or personal upheavals. Targets that explicitly told you "not interested" twelve months ago can suddenly become highly motivated. Success requires patience and discipline.

If your company is dependent on acquisitions for continued growth, you need to treat it as a dedicated business function—just like sales, marketing, or finance. This function might be managed internally, or it can be outsourced to an advisor.

Either way, their most significant role is to pipeline-manage the opportunities. Harvesting includes finessing the deal structures, maintaining consistent communication, and executing basic project management. Keeping all stakeholders accountable to what they agreed to do significantly enhances your chances of closing a clean transaction.

4. Prioritize Relationship Building

When it comes to SME acquisitions, relationships are everything. Effective alignment between the buyer and the seller is critical to getting deals done, and more importantly, making them stick post-settlement.

You have the opportunity to shape your relationship with an acquisition prospect from the very first call. This evaluation extends through every subsequent meeting, email, and personal contact. At each interaction, both sides are informally assessing if they still want to do business with the other. This is the crucial, human side of the due diligence process.

An acquisition that looks spectacular on a spreadsheet or a preliminary Term Sheet is only the starting point. In many SME deals, immense value is destroyed by over-focusing on the numbers at the expense of the people. At some point in almost every transaction, emotions take hold and the deal becomes shaky—often for reasons completely unrelated to commercial logic.

When that friction occurs, a strong relationship built on the following elements is essential to getting the deal back on track:

• A shared, detailed understanding of why both parties are pursuing the transaction.

• A mutual commitment to transparency.

• Open, regular communication loops.

• Commercial trust developed by both sides consistently delivering on what they promised.

5. Define and Refine the Deal Early

Preliminary transaction documents—such as Term Sheets, Memorandums of Understanding (MOUs), and Heads of Agreement (HOAs)—are grossly underused in SME transactions. This usually happens because parties try to minimize early legal costs, jump straight to a formal contract, or mistakenly feel everyone is already "on the same page."

Used correctly, a well-structured preliminary document smooths the path forward and dramatically increases your chances of completion. By taking the time to document exactly what you think you have agreed to, you quickly surface areas of disagreement or misunderstanding.

As soon as a deal becomes likely, write the core terms down and share them. Even if you start on the back of an envelope, it is a discipline that professional acquirers must adopt. A solid framework focuses both buyers and sellers on the critical operational items that extend far beyond the purchase price and settlement date.

A lack of early clarity on these common friction points can easily kill an otherwise good deal:

• Due Diligence scope, access, and timing.

• Deal financing structures and milestones.

• Exclusivity periods in negotiations.

• Transition and handover arrangements for the outgoing owner.

• The ongoing treatment and retention of key employees.

• Restrictive covenants and non-compete agreements.

6. Execute Rigorous Project Management

If you reach the point where a deal is commercially viable and documented on paper, you still have a critical final mountain to climb. While there is genuine excitement at this stage, it often brings a false sense of security that the rest of the transaction will simply fall into place automatically.

This is exactly the moment when a wave of new players is introduced to the deal: accountants, lawyers, landlords, financiers, and other specialist advisors. While they all have vital roles to play, many of them are not as personally invested in the success of the deal as the buyer and seller.

Unless someone explicitly owns the acquisition project, coordinates communications, and actively manages all these moving pieces, your timeline will drift. When a timeline drifts, the momentum stalls, and the probability of the deal collapsing climbs significantly. Someone must drive the process across the finish line.

All the best, Michael

Your Next Step: Validate the Numbers Before You Buy

An acquisition looks great on paper until you dig into the target's actual data. If you have identified a potential acquisition target, do not rely solely on their marketing materials or broker sheets.

I help growth-focused SME owners analyze target financials and conduct initial commercial due diligence to uncover risks, verify transferable value, and ensure the deal structure makes genuine commercial sense.

Let’s ensure your next acquisition is a true growth asset, not an expensive distraction. Call me directly or drop me a message for a confidential, advisory discussion.

Contact Michael for a Pre-acquisition Review

Join other Australian SME owners who receive our monthly breakdown on how to build, protect, and realize the true value of their businesses.

Subscribe